Aquarium and Pond UV Sterilizer, Clarifier Reviews; Problems, Bulbs

aquarium and pond UV posts, information, articles, resources, blogs

AQUARIUM AND POND UV STERILIZER REVIEW/ ARTICLES;
Information Articles (Posts), Ideas, Comments, & Links to even more Information about how UV (UVC) Sterilization works in Aquariums/ Ponds.
For a COMPLETE up to date article about aquarium and pond uv sterilization, please visit this site:
UV Sterilization in Aquariums and Ponds; How it works

For all Articles, from basic to advanced, such as UVC, Watts, mW/cm2, please scroll down the Right Side Bar of this site for easy links

UVC, Watts, Microwatts

 

Revised: 12/8/14

UVC, Watts, Microwatts, Joules, & Light Penetration

This article/post is intended to give some basic understanding between the relationship of watts, microwatts, joules of UVC energy and how this translates to UV Sterilizer effectiveness.

Please keep in mind that the diagram in this article is based on air penetration, so some extrapolation is necessary for use in water applications (which is the primary intention of this article, although the principles apply to UVC air sterilization devices as well)
UVC Air Sterilization Devices

What is a Watt/Microwatt?

One Joule of energy = 1,000 milliWatt seconds = 1,000,000 microWatt seconds
One joule is the amount of energy required to perform the following actions:

• The work done by a force of one newton traveling through a distance of one meter (a newton is the unit of force equal to the amount of force required to accelerate a mass of one kilogram at a rate of one meter per second per second);
• The work required to move an electric charge of one coulomb* (the amount of electric charge transported by a current of 1 ampere in 1 second) through an electrical potential difference of one volt; or one coulomb volt, with the symbol C•V;
• The work done to produce power of one watt continuously for one second; or one watt second (compare kilowatt hour), with the symbol W•s. Thus a kilowatt hour is 3,600,000 joules or 3.6 megajoules;
• The kinetic energy of a 2 kg mass moving at a velocity of 1 m/s. The energy is linear in the mass but quadratic in the velocity, being given by E = ½mv²;
we measure UV-C intensity in Micro-Watts that strike one square centimeter of surface area.
Reference: What is a coulomb?



UVC Penetration;
A quote from an advanced sterilization article:
UV Sterilization; How a UV Sterilizer Works


"The emission or light intensity of a UVC germicidal light bulb is usually expressed in a term called "microwatts per square centimeter" (Mw/cm2). The maximum intensity provided by a single UV-C Bulb is at its surface.
So, if we calculate the surface area of the UVC lamp and only use that area which effectively emits UVC light rays, the effective area of UVC transmission will be established. Basic mathematics will show that the surface area of a cylindrical tube is ‘pie’ D L.

Next extrapolate this effective area of UVC transmission as having a screen with squares 1 centimeter in size. Each of these cm2 areas now, for measurement purposes, emits a UVC lamp intensity measured in microwatts, in other words; the term microwatts/cm2. UVC light intensity decreasingly varies as the distance from the UVC light increases.

Put more simply (a non scientific analogy); The amount of wattage will also increase penetration, as a higher watt UV-C bulb will generally have more Mw/cm2."

See this product link for high output Straight Tube UV Bulbs:
http://www.americanaquariumproducts.com/T5T8UVBulbs.html

"In my own experiments I have used 15 watt and 25 watt UVC bulbs in exactly the same unit (both were 18”), if wattage were only considered there would be a 60% increase in effectiveness, however I only observed a about a 25% increase.
When I used a 30 Watt UVC bulb in a unit with over twice the exposure as the 15 Watt, the kill rate more than doubled. From my experience, if you increase wattage (and Mw/cm2) you need to also increase the volume of water to maximize the higher watt bulb.
Experiments can also be safely conducted with standard household light bulbs to correlate penetration. For this start with a 7 watt clear bulb (such as a Christmas bulb) and place varying thicknesses of paper/ cardboard in front of the bulb and measure when penetration stops. Continue this with higher and higher wattage bulbs."


UVC Intensity The Diagram to the left can give a rough comparison of distance as per UVC energy as expressed by MW/cm2 in Air transmission.
The dose applied by an UV-C lamp installation is a function of the lamp output, the intensity factor, and time. As an equation; Intensity x Exposure time= microwatt seconds/cm2.

As an example, a 9 watt UVC lamp at one inch from the lamp is found by this formula:
9 x 127 = 1143 mW/cm2.
Since many bacteria such as Vibrio require a UVC exposure of 6500 mW/cm2 or more, this means an exposure time of 5.68 seconds is required to kill this pathogen


Now let me point out that even though I have published this diagram, please use this as a rough guide only, as I have found inaccuracies in it. To be more blunt; I have found the distance, wattage, and flow rate to be the MOST IMPORTANT factors in determining exposure/effectiveness. This diagram is STATIC and does NOT take into consideration the dynamics of UVC radiation penetration for which I have yet to find a good formula to demonstrate this (even in University studies).

What is often missing in any equations I have seen is the dynamics of water flow geometry, actual water flow, and wattage. The bottom line is to use this table and others you might find elsewhere with “a grain of salt” noting that these are static and even then are flawed when true output via wattage is taken into consideration.

Further Reading, References, Product Resources:

*UV Sterilization; How it works for Aquariums, Ponds, & more


*Harmful Pathogens: The Threat, mJ/cm2

*http://www.hygienitech.com/Hygienitech%20UV-C%20Light%20Primer.pdf

*http://www.solartanic.com/index_022.htm


UV Bulb; Replacement Lamps

The very best UV Replacement Lamps/Bulbs at competitive prices!

Labels: , , , , ,

7 Comments:

Blogger Sterile Conditioner UV said...

Please advise where the Ultraviolet Intensity Factor table is from. These numbers are quite a bit higher than the Westinghouse Sterilamp Publication that I have been using.
Thanks

10:47 AM  
Blogger Carl said...

This came from a website that has since been "parked" (as happens quite often)

If you have a chart your feel is more accurate, please feel free to share.
My findings (as stated here) do not necessarily agree with this table, which it is only meant as a guide for hot cathode UVC lamps

12:43 PM  
Blogger Sterile Conditioner UV said...

I've found that chart at a number of sites and was trying to determine who's correct. I'd like to use your chart as the numbers present better results for kill rates, but whatever the correct numbers are, need to be found.
Here is what Westinghouse presents: http://www.electro-tech-online.com/custompdfs/2012/02/UVC20Selection20and20Information20Guide.pdf
This is from Carrier's website.

1:44 PM  
Anonymous ObM said...

Hey there!

Nice article, just a reminder to people reading.

You need to keep in mind is the wattage of UVC emission not the wattage of the lamp.

I have a Phillips TUV 8W T5 UV-C lamp:
http://www.ecat.lighting.philips.com/l/lamps/uv/germicidal/tuv-tl-mini/928001104013_na//

You can see in the specifications on that page:
This is an 8 Watt Lamp, but it only throws out 2.4 Watts of UVC Radiation.

So calculations should be based on 2.4 Watts (not 8).

Same goes for a 30 watt T8 lamp.
According to one spec sheet from Phillips, The UVC Radiation for their 30W T8 is 12 watts.

Good luck everyone!

9:16 PM  
Blogger Steve said...

ObM;
This is correct.
However the calculations here assume that one is using a low pressure mercury UVC lamp.
The actual output is 35% useful UVC irradiation.

This number would result in 2.8 watts, close to the 2.4 number you provided. This indicates these lamps are slightly lower output than some, but still in the ball park of being a "good" uv bulb to use.

However if one uses a medium pressure UV bulb, the actual useful UVC output is lass than 10% and thus an 8 watt bulb of this type would produce less than 1 watt of useful UVC energy.

My point is the numbers of say 30 gph per watt of UV bulb for level one Sterilization is ASSUMING a low pressure UV bulb.

All bets are off if one purchases one of the many cheapie medium pressure bulbs being peddled on eBay and Amazon.

See also:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultraviolet_germicidal_irradiation

11:28 AM  
Blogger Steve said...

ObM and all- here is another article that deals with UV bulb emission. More specifically what is the actual useful output of a UV bulb. Take a look if you are interested.

http://www.uvsterilizerreview.com/2013/10/actual-uv-c-emission-from-uv-bulb.html

10:04 AM  
Blogger Steve said...

Here is the link for the article about UV bulb emission

http://www.uvsterilizerreview.com/2013/10/actual-uv-c-emission-from-uv-bulb.html

10:28 AM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home